Should a Christian Vote for Mitt Romney?

Due to the nomination of Mitt Romney as the Republican candidate for the Presidency, I’ve been asked many times in the past couple of months whether or not it’s appropriate for a Christian to vote for a Mormon as President of the United States.  With this November’s election quickly approaching, I think it’s time to finally offer my personal opinion on the issue.

The first thing that Christians need to understand is that Jesus isn’t running for political office.  This effectively means that the perfect candidate is never going to exist, making our choice always that of choosing the candidate we believe is least flawed – something that can at times prove distasteful.  Because of this, there are those Christians who either abstain from the political process or who participate half-heartedly in it, but I would argue that such behavior abdicates the requirement to be salt and light (Matthew 5:13,14) among a self-governing people.  Instead, what the people of Scripture should do is apply Scriptural principles to this process of selection.

The Bible outlines for us two basic ways by which we are to judge the selection of individuals for public service: their personal qualifications and how their views on what defines appropriate government compare with those of Scripture.  As I discussed last year in Choosing Government Leaders 101, the high Biblical standard set for the personal qualifications of public officials is that they be demonstrably capable and successful, that they be honest people of deep integrity who are not interested in personal gain from such positions, and that they be people who love Jehovah (Exodus 18:21).  And while I have sincere and unbridgeable issues with Mormonism regarding the last of these, of the two viable candidates for the Presidency, Mitt Romney clearly wins this battle.

However, when we take into consideration the issue of how the candidates view what defines appropriate government, things are not quite as clear.  In the interests of brevity I must hold my remarks in this area of thought to those regarding the redistribution of wealth, but for those interested in deeper discussion, I recommend reviewing the many previous articles under the Government category.  In short, according to the Eighth Commandment (which forbids theft), government is not allowed to redistribute the wealth of its citizens, and a person of any faith (or lack thereof) may hold such a position.  It is here that the Romneycare of Massachusetts becomes a near-fatal flaw for the Republican candidate, though, as it represents redistribution on a grand scale.  For this reason I argued strenuously against Mr. Romney earlier this year during the Republican primaries.

Yet the fact remains that the redistributive tendencies of President Obama far exceed those of Mr. Romney, and the Republican challenger’s vow to immediately repeal Obamacare if elected is a promising sign that the former governor is changing his views on the scourge of compassionate government (an ideology that is leading us inevitably into the abyss).  Furthermore, when you look at the current Administration’s stance and record regarding abortion, Supreme Court nominees, the family, borders and foreign policy, the C+ earned by Mitt Romney is far preferable to the F earned by President Obama in the area of appropriate government.  Again, Mr. Romney is the winner.

I cannot overstate how close planet Earth is to the precipice in these times.  Western Europe is falling like dominos under the weight of socialism’s endgame; the tiger of communist China threatens all of Asia; the specter of totalitarianism rises again in power-mad Russia; Central America is owned by drug cartels; the Middle East is aflame and Islam is positively bursting at the seams with jihad.  When America falls to the internal weakness of passing the threshold of majority social dependency (and we are so very close to this today), the goodness and strength of this nation will quickly thereafter be lost, and with it the world’s chance of surviving the relentless onslaught of the many forms of Darkness so astutely arrayed against it.

We have but a few years left to begin turning this tide of Darkness.  A second term of Barack Obama will essentially cement the failure of America, while a first term of Mitt Romney may yet give us a fighting chance.  A President Romney may not completely turn this ship around (for that is largely up to us), but I believe he will slow its progress toward destruction.  And that is enough to earn the vote of the Christian this November.

Yet there is much more to it than that.  If we Christians are unhappy about the candidates before us, we have only ourselves to blame, for the sheer number of Christians in America dictates that we should positively own the political process.  This means that stalwart, solid people who hold deeply to Biblical values of government (which are essentially enshrined in our amazing Constitution) should absolutely dominate politics – from the local school board to the White House.  But Christians have proven too apathetic, too unconcerned, too uncommitted, too busy, too Biblically illiterate or too cowed by their secularist adversaries to get involved, and have thereby lost the high ground of politics to others.  Let us not think that God will hold us guiltless if the world plunges into Darkness during our watch.

There is much work for Christians to do, and it is my opinion that this work begins with a vote for Mitt Romney as the next President of the United States.

4 thoughts on “Should a Christian Vote for Mitt Romney?

  1. Well, after considered thought and prayer, I decided that a small post on this subject was warranted. I have had several acquaintances accuse me of NOT being Christian because I am supporting Romney for President of these United (under God) States. I am stating simply that I believe that Romney and the LDS Church know my Savior, Jesus Christ (albeit in an imperfect way perhaps). I will also say that I am certain that Mormons and their faith is not that of a cult. While there may well be a large gap between the faith I act on and the faith that I understand to be that of the Mormons, I believe that Mitt Romney can become one of the most positively transforming persons of the 21st century. Because of that belief, and all of the confirming evidence that supports that position, I (too) believe he is the only choice at this time for President of these United (under God) States.

    If you have an open mind and are not of the persuasion of “don’t confuse me with the facts, my mind is made up!”, then I highly recommend this good, short and concise read that can help inform the un (or under) informed.

    And if you are not sure about picking up a book at this time, this might be a good primer.

    Just my 2 cents, and I am convinced that there is but one way to vote in November…

  2. Great work, Pastor. I really believe the last four years of disastrous national polictics is starting to reverse the plolitical apathy in this country – not just for Christians but all citizens. And I also believe we will succeed in turning around this great great country.

  3. Since His name is in the title of their church, I would have to say that “Mormons” are Christians. The official name is The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, Couldn’t be more clear to me that they believe and worshop Jesus Christ as their Savior just as ALL Christians do. If all Christian religions believed in the all of the same tenets then there would be one Christian church but since there are many interpretations then that is where your belief and testimony come from concerning which church you choose to attend. Jesus taught us to be tolerant and forgiving and yet I see many “Christians” not practicing what he has taught us………..kinda ironic!

    • Tom

      With all due respect, I must challenge your reasoning on this. Putting “Jesus Christ” in the name of a church doesn’t necessarily make it Christian. If the Watchtower Society changed it’s name to Jesus’ Witnesses instead of Jehovah’s Witnesses, would they then be Christian? Or if Islam changed the name of Allah to Jesus, would they then be Christian as well?

      It’s much better to compare the LDS (or any) belief system with the clarity of Scripture to come to such conclusions. And unless the LDS Church has disowned the tenets of its founders (Smith, Young, etc.) without my hearing of it, the LDS Church is sorely lacking in this regard.

      There is much in Mormonism to commend it socially, and Mormons have proven capable of understanding and implementing Biblical values of government. Christianesque it may be, but truly Christian it is not. A belief system must hold a proper understanding of Christ Himself in order to qualify as Christian.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s